Why Portugal changes the financial planning conversation
In the United States, testamentary freedom is broad: you can generally leave your assets to whomever you choose through a will or trust, subject to spousal elective share rights in community property and common law states. Portugal operates under a fundamentally different framework. Portuguese succession law includes legitimate heirs (herdeiros legitimarios) — typically the surviving spouse, children, and parents — who are entitled to a mandatory share (legitima) of the deceased’s estate regardless of what the will says. This forced heirship provision can override testamentary wishes for assets subject to Portuguese jurisdiction.
The interaction between US and Portuguese succession law creates complexity that does not exist for Americans living exclusively in the United States. If you establish Portuguese financial residency and hold assets in both countries, the question of which country’s succession law applies to which assets becomes critical. EU Regulation 650/2012 (the Brussels IV Regulation) generally applies the succession law of the deceased’s habitual residence to their entire estate — meaning that if you die as a Portuguese resident, Portuguese forced heirship rules may apply to your worldwide assets unless you have made a specific election in your will choosing the law of your nationality (US law) to govern your succession.
This nationality election is the single most important financial planning action for Americans establishing Portuguese residency. By including a clear clause in your will stating that US law (specifically the law of your US state of domicile) should govern the succession of your entire estate, you can override Portuguese forced heirship and maintain American testamentary freedom. This election must be explicit, properly documented, and ideally prepared by an attorney familiar with both US estate law and EU Regulation 650/2012.